Thursday, December 30, 2021

The Furrowed Middlebrow Dozen 2021

Oh, what a terrible year for the world at large, but what a wonderful year of reading! I've worked from home on average three days a week this year, spending two days in the office, and it has really affected my quality of life even more than I could have imagined. Subtracting the stress and strain of a commute, adding the comfort of wearing shorts and a t-shirt for work, subtracting all the distractions of the office (and the shady neighborhood in which it's located), adding the mood-lightening sunshine our apartment receives most days and the mental and physical health benefits of lunchtime workouts, it's been a revelation of how civilized life can be even while getting one's work done just as well as ever. And this of course is not to mention that that commute time can now be used for reading, so it has been an extraordinarily fruitful year! 

Of course, if I could make the horrors and frustrations of covid for others go away with a snap of the finger, I would happily give up these benefits, but alas I don't have that ability, so I will make do by being very thankful and aware of how lucky we've been. And for now, at least, our office is continuing to allow us to work from home three days a week indefinitely, so here's hoping 2022 will be another excellent bookish year.

Even allowing for the 12 non-blog-related titles I mentioned last week in my first ever UNfurrowed Dozen (see here), it was terribly difficult getting this list down to 12 blog-related titles. With my addictive reading of numerous titles by a few authors, the list could have been completely dominated by D. E. Stevenson, Monica Stirling, and Violet Trefusis, so I've had to rigorously limit myself to one or two titles by each. DES's The Tall Stranger and The Blue Sapphire, two of our titles being released next week from Dean Street Press, were near misses, as were the two early non-mystery titles by Felicity Shaw, later better known as mystery writer Anne Morice (see here). Then there was the delightfully enjoyable (but pricey!) Emily, by Hilda Stewart Reid, which I discussed here. Two children's titles, Dorita Fairlie Bruce's The Bees on Drumwhinnie (1952), one of her historical Colmskirk novels, and Catherine Christian's Diana Takes a Chance (1940), which I didn't get around to reviewing, would also likely have made the cut in a slower year.

And as you'll see, I'm forced to risk irritating and annoying you with my top pick of the year. It was a choice between being a coy little tease or actually lying to you about the best book I read this year, so I've gone with the former…

And now, in the flesh, I give you the Dozen.

12) MARY CLIVE (as HANS DUFFY), Seven by Seven (1933)

Best known for her later memoir/novel
Christmas with the Savages, Clive wrote four earlier novels using the Duffy pseudonym. The other three have proven impossible to get my hands on, but this one was a delight, evoking (if not bettering) Evelyn Waugh and demonstrating once and for all how unjust the process by which some books are remembered and treasured and some fall by the wayside really is.

11) ISOBEL STRACHEY, First Impressions (1945)

And here is perhaps another example of said injustice. Strachey was taken quite seriously in her time, and is an absolutely brilliant metaphorist above all else ("The curate stood beside him in a curious toppling position. His clothes looked as though they were being blown off him although there was no wind."), but of course she's now forgotten as well. I read three of her novels this year (one still to review) and have four more to look forward to in the New Year.

10) IVY COMPTON-BURNETT, Daughters and Sons (1937)

My favorite novel yet by one of my favorite authors, though one that most readers either love or hate. If you must read just one ICB, this one, described as "one of the lightest and most comic of her novels" (though still delightfully bleak and morbid), is the one to try.

9) DOROTHY LAMBERT, Scotch Mist (1936)

Most of you know that in 2020 Dean Street Press reprinted Dorothy Lambert's wonderful village comedy Much Dithering, from 1938. I've since read a handful more of Lambert's novels, with varying results, but this year I found another treasure in this holiday frolic set in a Scottish boarding-house reluctantly managed by the increasingly impoverished Neil McPherson. Alas, more or less impossible to find, but perhaps one day we'll be able to reprint this one too?

8) NAOMI ROYDE-SMITH, Outside Information (1941)

A bit rough around the edges as it was compiled as events were actively unfolding, and perhaps all the better for it, this combination of diaries and letters (including a few from friends like Margaret Kennedy) by a prolific novelist provides some irresistible reportage on the Blitz, supplemented with humor, occasional poignancy, and vivid personality. An excellent complement to Frances Faviell's
A Chelsea Concerto.

7) D. M. LARGE, The Quiet Place (1941)

For somewhat lighter reading about the early days of the war and the Blitz (albeit from a distance), this novel about the Irish O'Hara sisters, who open their quiet country home to paying guests seeking escape from bombs is a lovely, funny, warm-hearted book about the idiosyncrasies of its eccentric characters, who find the war creeping up on them even in the Irish countryside.

6) DOROTHEA TOWNSHEND, A Lion, a Mouse, and a Motorcar (1915)

Just what the doctor ordered for pure giddy escape, this utterly daft spy adventure/comedy rollicks along like nobody's business. Delia Gwyn, a rector’s daughter, finds herself swept into international intrigue, complete with Russian princesses, a short stint in a Spanish prison, a near miss of an assassination attempt, and a dramatic rescue from a kidnapping attempt. It's completely implausible, but no less fun for that, and I send my thanks again to Kathy Reed, who dared to send her vanishingly rare copy of the book to San Francisco for me to read. It has happily returned safely home now.

5) D. E. STEVENSON, Kate Hardy (1947)

VERY difficult narrowing down the DES titles I read this year to only one. Many of the 11 novels we're reprinting in just a few days (see
here if you've somehow escaped knowing this!) were, believe it or not, new to me this year, and I loved them all. The Tall Stranger and The Blue Sapphire, mentioned above, are loaded with charm, and Young Mrs Savage is a perfect holiday story. But I finally settled, for purposes of this list, on this lesser-known gem, which I never got round to writing about in any detail. A novelist in the immediate postwar years spontaneously buys a home in the country and finds the country may not allow her much more time for writing than London does! (This one has been virtually impossible to find, but not anymore, as of next week!)

4) MONICA STIRLING, Dress Rehearsal (1952)
3) MONICA STIRLING, Ladies with a Unicorn (1953)

The author I read more than any other this year might well have dominated this list if I'd allowed her two, but these two titles represent, for me, her best efforts in two different styles.
Dress Rehearsal is largely a comedy set in a girls' boarding school and, despite the publisher's assurance that it's not autobiographical, reflects in almost every detail Stirling's own upbringing. Ladies with a Unicorn, meanwhile, is in what I call Stirling's Proust Lite style, with its characters' present-day, postwar dramas largely filtered through their wartime traumas. Scintillating elegance and high fashion in the Roman film industry combines with gritty recollections of darker days, and I found the combination impossible to put down.

2) VIOLET TREFUSIS, Tandem (1933)

Dear Violet could also have dominated this list, but this one is the clear winner for me out of her six novels available in English (all of which I read this year, as well as cursing the literary stars that her other two haven't been translated from French). Beginning in 1892 with sisters Pénélope and Iréne in girlhood,
Tandem soon leaps forward to show us the girls getting married and then their very different (but intriguingly echoing) married lives. The characters are possibly based on Violet's friends, Anna de Noailles and Princesse Marthe Bibesco (mentioned in last week's UNfurrowed Dozen), also novelists. Broderie Anglaise, about Violet's romantic triangle with Vita Sackville-West and Virginia Woolf, has always got more attention than this novel, understandably but definitely not deservedly.

1) ?????????????????, ????????????????

And finally… Just in the past couple of weeks, my planned list has been upended by an email revealing (and then sending) a manuscript of an unpublished novel, previously thought to have been lost, by a favorite author. I can't say much more (and not just because of a perverse urge to tease), but the novel is sooooooo lovely and brilliant and funny and poignant, it has to occupy this spot. It's not any exaggeration to say it's by far my favorite read of the year, and I hope it will some day be a favorite of yours too…

And there, teasing aside, you have my favorite reads of the year. Now it's time for you to share your happiest discoveries!


  1. Agh, you tease!
    Cannot wait to see who and what this is and if you're going to publish it.
    Nevertheless, wishing you both a delightful Happy New Year. May it be filled with only goodness, joy, peace, and excellent health! Hugs from moi

  2. Argh! What a cliffhanger! Many good wishes for a safe and healthy year ahead with more excellent reading AND MUCH MORE PUBLISHING.
    (I got a really good promotion early this year but I can't say it's made my financial situation better as all additional income has gone on books recommended by FM).

  3. What a tease, I hope you can reveal and publish the mysterious book soon. Added to that, I would vote for Scotch Mist (in part because I loved Much Dithering) and The Quiet Place toward the top of the list of those I would most like to buy in Furrowed Middlebrow editions. I do have the upcoming DES Kindle titles on pre-order already. In my youth I found Kate Hardy (along with The Baker's Daughter and Rosabelle Shaw) the least comfortable of DES reads, in large part because they addressed serious issues like the class system, and now I value them for that very reason.

    I will have to do another comment later about my top reads in 2021.

    Happy New Year wishes to you and all who read this blog and/or Middlebrow fiction in general.


  4. Books I read and loved in 2021: First off, the two sets of books published by Furrowed Middlebrow had some real gems. I think my favorites from this wonderful selection include Four Gardens, Swiss Summer, Dear Hugo and Apricot Sky, but there were a lot of great reads included. Authors included in the Furrowed Middlebrow time frame include Patricia Moyes, whose first book, Dead Men Don't Ski was published just in time for her to be included continued to publish for another couple of decades and her later books have been being released in Kindle format and several have been on sale. Night Ferry to Death and The Curious Affair of the Third Dog stick in my head, but I have found the entire series to be enjoyable. And E. C. R. Lorac has also had more and more of her books appear in print/ebook/audibook. I enjoyed Two Way Murder and The Last Escape as well as Crossed Skies which appeared using her alternative name of Carol Carnac.

    In newly written books, for those who enjoy fantasy, I recommend the works of Ben Aaronovitch - Rivers of London series, this summer What Abigal Did That Summer was a fun fill in novella. And I have also been enjoying the Penric and Desdemona series by Lois M. Bujold, of which I really enjoyed her first novel length item in this largely novella series, Assassins of Thassalon.

    Happy Reading to All.


  5. So much suspense! I can't wait to hear what the number one book is but, until then, will busy myself tracking down some of your other picks. I'm especially intrigued by Scotch Mist and The Quiet Place. Best wishes for 2022!

  6. Ah, what a tease you are. Your list is intriguing enough without that cliffhanger. I am reminded I would love to read more Isobel Stachey.

  7. I haven't read any of these, not even the ICB though I have it waiting - and, of course, I have the Townshend ready to read, and expect I will next year. My own list just up, and easier to track down :D

  8. If even one of the "new" titles gives me as much pleasure as Much Dithering or especially, Apricot SKy, I will be happy.
    Thanks for all of it, Scott, and certainly, all best wishes for the year ahead!

  9. So Celia Buckmaster's unpublished manuscript is going to print.

    Is it set in England or Burma? Or perhaps Madeira?

    All best for 2022.


    1. Ha! Excellent guess, Steve, but incorrect I'm afraid. :-)

  10. Ooooooh! a cliffhanger! I am absolutely loving DES' "Five Windows" at the moment and it would have made my top books for 2021 had I not been putting together blog posts on 31 December. I'm pretty sure it will be a top read of 2022 instead. And I'll be adding some of the new ones to my birthday wishlist forthwith! Happy New Year and thank you for all you do.

  11. Oh what a cliffhanger. Your list reminded me I have Much Dithering on my Kindle so will read that soonish. I wrote down several authors and titles from this post, thanks.

  12. Oooh I'm so intrigued by your mysterious #1 read. . . can we hope that it will be a future FM title? Looking back I see that I read 5 FM titles in 2021 and loved them all. I think The Woods in Winter was my favorite, such a lovely story. Thanks again for sharing all these great books with us!


NOTE: The comment function on Blogger is notoriously cranky. If you're having problems, try selecting "Name/URL" or "Anonymous" from the "Comment as" drop-down (be sure to "sign" your comment, though, so I know who dropped by). Some people also find it easier using a browser like Firefox or Chrome instead of Internet Explorer.

But it can still be a pain, and if you can't get any of that to work, please email me at I do want to hear from you!