Sunday, March 1, 2015

EILEEN HELEN CLEMENTS, Cherry Harvest (1943)

This book is another excellent reminder of the need to take contemporary reviews with a grain of salt.  I mentioned it in a post while back on books added to my "to read" list, and quoted a review which described it as follows: “An amusing tale of mystery concerning a strange assortment of people heading to a country estate where they will be living during the duration of WWII but they have a lot of adjusting to do with each other and then there is the matter of the dead body.”

More or less accurate, I suppose, except for the minor details that the country estate is actually a girls' school, and the assortment of people heading there are actually going only for a weekend visit during a half-term break rather than for the duration of the war.  But the reviewer did get the dead body right, and it is certainly a strange assortment of folks visiting and/or working at the school.

For starters, there's Duncan Cary, who has been doing important intelligence work to develop a method of stopping German bombers, but he has tired himself out to the point of nervous breakdown, so he goes on leave and escapes back to Burbury, the estate on which he had spent happy childhood times with his cousin.  But he finds it now occupied by an evacuated girls' school, and this particular weekend is half-term, with only a few of the students remaining.  He is accompanied on the train down by two sets of parents, the Willows (very "navy" as the jacket blurb says) and the Passmores (class-conscious and petty—perhaps the name comes from their attempts to "pass" as higher class than they actually are?), as well as by Anthony Lord, a 22-year-old RAF pilot in pursuit of the older woman he hopelessly loves.

Said older woman is Celia Staire, a widow from an unhappy marriage, raising her young daughter while working for the school.  It soon emerges that she is, in fact, the current owner of Burbury, but her poverty has forced her to let it to Miss Knowles, the school's headmistress.  Celia's daughter Belinda, the Passmores' daughter Vicky, the Willows' twins Margaret and Daphne, and Jill Marrison, who, despite her only relative's being off in Cairo, becomes the center of several visitors' attention during the course of the weekend, all make occasional appearances, often for light comic relief. 

Two unexpected guests, Mr. Brent and Miss Hartland, also turn up, both claiming to be friends of Jill's absent relative, and due to various odd circumstances which rather strain credibility, they, along with Duncan, are included in an unlikely gathering for picnics and weekend festivities.  All the while, Anthony tries to convince Celia of his viability as a husband, Duncan heads on into his breakdown while the children adopt him as one of their own and refuse to leave his side, the imminent harvest of cherries for the school's jam is threatened, and suspicious doings, "careless talk," and even murder unfolds in all directions.

I know that many of you, like me, enjoy wartime fiction about life on the home front, and if you also like fairly loosy-goosy, character-based mysteries, then Cherry Harvest will be an enjoyable afternoon or two of reading.  I wanted to really love this one and be able to rave about it as a lost treasure, but ultimately it was rather like a batch of cherry jam that's perfectly tasty but doesn't quite set properly.

There were certainly some amusements here, though.  On occasion, the superficial, babbling Mrs. Passmore and her worn-down, cranky husband provide some comic relief, as when they pass through Oxford on the train ride down:

The train slid to a standstill, and they surveyed the crowded platform.

"Dreaming spires," said Mrs. Passmore, and moved her eyes from one empty slot-machine to another. "Who said that, once?"

"You, probably," said her husband, and heaved his large form into the corridor.

And I noted several interesting wartime references that provide a feel of the times, as when—predictably—the French mistress comes in for some suspicion:

"You don't think, Celia, do you, that Mademoiselle is just a wee bit Vichy."

"Vichy? Maddy? No, of course not. How do you mean, though?"

"Well, I don't know. Just an attitude she takes up, sometimes, when we're listening to the news or someone makes a remark. I can't quite explain. As if she weren't excessively fond of the English."

"Well, she probably isn't. Lots of people aren't, you know."

And Burbury itself can be added to the long list of country estates whose slow crumbling is bemoaned in the literature of the time.  Celia herself, who owns the property, is matter-of-fact about it, but Mrs. Passmore, who aspires to all the trappings of the upper classes, sees Burbury's disarray as tragic and disturbing, and her description is a vivid one:

Stella looked up at the stone pediment over the doorway, which bore a much defaced coat-of-arms surmounted by some crumbling stone bird. Who were the people who had once Iived here? Antiquity, when it was decently presented in grey stone, with smooth lawns, trim hedges, and a mass of colour in the herbaceous borders, was really her idea of perfection for a house—if only one had the money to keep it up. These people obviously hadn't, and when that was the case, the oldness of a house chilled and terrified, suggesting ghosts and darkness, draughts, cobwebs and spiders. This place—Stella glanced around her at the wide expanse of tangled garden, where sudden flashes of blue showed where delphiniums reared themselves like flames against the stone walls, with its weeds and uncut lawns, its lichened apple-trees—this place was a fantastic mixture of the worst and the best, of discomfort and a vague disturbing beauty.

Cherry Harvest was apparently Clements' sixth novel, and features a brief appearance by Alister Woodhead, who would become a prominent character in a series of spy novels Clements wrote, extending through to the early 1960s.  Woodhead is virtually a non-entity in this volume, but he becomes a central character in later books. 


  1. I may have to get onto it since you had earlier turned me on to the "genre" of murders in English girls' schools, starting with Christie's "Cat Among the Pigeons!" Tom

    1. I still hope to have a whole list of school stories for grownups pulled together and posted soon, Tom. But in the meantime, I have two or three more of them to write about here in the next few weeks...

  2. Even though you say this doesn't quite work, I really want to read this based on the book jacket and your description. The two sets of parents and the young man sound very enjoyable. But the author looks to be pretty rare.

    1. I tracked this down from the library, Grace, but I think I remember that there were copies available for not TOO much. That may have changed though. It's an enjoyable enough few hours of reading, but I wouldn't recommend spending all your savings on it!

  3. I look forward to your reviews (always really excellent!), and I appreciate that you’ve been so generous with them as of late.

    A crumbling old place like Burbury is my favorite sort of setting.


    1. Oh, thank you, Jane. I'm glad to know the reviews are appreciated. I don't do as many as I'd like because it seems to take me forever to write them, but I have come across several interesting books lately, so more will be coming soon.

      Hmmm, perhaps I should do a list of novels set on crumbling country estates?

  4. Sounds pretty good, despite the plum puddingyness. Great analogy, btw.

    1. You might enjoy it, Lisa. It certainly has its moments. Just, perhaps, not quite enough of them...

  5. Just read this and I almost 100% agree with you. I thought the story could have been told more concisely as a novella. The excessive amount of chit chat in this book nearly drove me mad. There is hardly any action at all related to the plot until the book is well past the halfway mark. And a thriller of any sort (this barely passes muster as either a detective novel or espionage adventure) in which the murder does not occur until page 116 is bound to infuriate diehard mystery fans. Those types of readers do not make up most of your blog audience, I know, but I have to offer that as a warning to anyone who reads crime fiction mostly for the plot. I differ with your opinion of Woodhead's appearance in the book. He is instrumental in explaining to everyone else the various nebulous mysteries and gets angry with Celia for, he thinks, withholding vital info. As a veteran detective fiction reader I spotted the spies instantly and was onto their shenanigans the moment each was introduced. I thought the boobytrap murder was rather ingenious even though the murder is dismissed by nearly everyone but Woodhead. I was bothered by the characters' seeming indifference about something so horrific.

    My post will be up next week at Pretty Sinister Books. I'll drop by again to leave the link.


NOTE: The comment function on Blogger is notoriously cranky. If you're having problems, try selecting "Name/URL" or "Anonymous" from the "Comment as" drop-down (be sure to "sign" your comment, though, so I know who dropped by). Some people also find it easier using a browser like Firefox or Chrome instead of Internet Explorer.

But it can still be a pain, and if you can't get any of that to work, please email me at I do want to hear from you!