Showing posts with label Maleficent Malingerers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Maleficent Malingerers. Show all posts

Friday, March 26, 2021

“My novels are hard not to put down”: IVY COMPTON-BURNETT, Men and Wives (1931)


I’m setting myself a bit of a challenge writing about Ivy Compton-Burnett, because Dame Ivy is a notoriously challenging author to write about (as well as to read). I love that she had the self-awareness to quip about her perpetual lack of mainstream popularity despite considerable critical acclaim (as quoted in the title of this post). And indeed, since her death in 1969, her books have continued to receive enthusiastic acclaim from the few while dodging any wider fanbase and peeping sporadically in and out of print.

Her original publisher, Gollancz, took the extraordinary step of releasing complete sets of her books in hardcover as late as 1984—something that happens with precious few modern authors and which reflects how seriously she was taken. Virago and Penguin Modern Classics published most of her novels in the 80s and 90s. The prestigious New York Review Books Classics have kept two of her titles, A House and Its Head (1935) and Manservant and Maidservant (1947), in print for a couple of decades now. In more recent years, Bloomsbury released e-books of most of her work (even including her disowned, autobiographical debut, Dolores (1911), the only one of her books not written in more or less the same unique, uncompromising style—primarily told via implausibly formal, philosophical dialogue and focused obsessively on the darker elements of nuclear family life in late Victorian years). Now, it appears that even those e-book versions have largely lapsed back out of print, so for her fans, few as they may be, it will be back to trolling second-hand shops and academic libraries to get hold of her.

Speaking of which, I must have discovered Dame Ivy when NYRB Classics released their two titles in about 2001. I loved both of them and went trolling second-hand shops for more. At a (now long defunct) bookstore on Irving Street in San Francisco, as I happily seized on and purchased a couple of her out-of-print titles, I remember being told by the owner that I would have had a wider selection to choose from but only a few days before, film director John Waters had been in the store and stocked up on Compton-Burnett himself. “You’re in good company,” she told me. Certainly interesting company, at least (whether John Waters would appreciate being called “good company” might be in some doubt), and I was sure I was on to something.


During my Dame Ivy kick of 2001-2002, I read six of her novels, and in the years since I’ve read a couple more, so Men and Wives makes my ninth in all, and my first since 2013. Though I always think of her as a favorite and even an “important” author, both generally and in my reading life, my sporadic indulgence in her work hardly suggests ardent passion, does it? And yet, when I noticed that, rather surprisingly, the San Francisco Public Library had five of her less well-known titles, I spontaneously put in holds for all five, and as soon as I glanced at the opening pages of Men and Wives, I fell headlong into it, shunting aside the other books I was already reading.

There’s usually a monster in Dame Ivy’s tales—often an egomaniacal, dictatorial parent. Here, that’s clearly Lady Harriet Haslam, a self-absorbed malingerer who whines and moans and stifles her three sons and one daughter as well as her dithering husband, Sir Godfrey. As with most of many members of this coveted character category (especially, it seems, in novels by women in this time period), Lady Harriet lavishes affection only with strings attached, and laces her devotions with scolds and mockery and devaluations:

“I am a torment to you all, and a burden on your hours that you never escape! But I am as much of a burden on my own, ten thousand times more of a burden. Griselda, my darling, don’t look distressed; don’t waste a thought on your harrowing old mother. Don’t think of me. Be happy.”

Ah, how many characters in novels by authors ranging from Barbara Pym to Richmal Crompton and from Elizabeth Eliot to D. E. Stevenson might have uttered those very same words! (And how they bring back memories of my own mother…)

But Lady Harriet has apparently behaved in this way for too long and her power has somewhat abated. Her children are grown, though still unmarried, and are no longer so easily cowed, and they and Sir Godfrey seem to share a subtle, mutually understood resistance to her, even while Sir Godfrey spouts his adoration and respect with every breath. Harriet is driven to more extreme measures, which I won't detail here, but even in her defeat (if that’s what it is) we see her influences passed on and her claws scratching at those around her.


There’s far too much here to unpack and summarize. There’s Bellamy the rector, whose wife has left him and set her sights first on the local doctor and then on Harriet’s oldest son. There’s Mr. Spong, a neighbor, who loses his wife and attaches himself, rather depressingly, to the Haslam family during their ups and downs. There’s a household of widowed and unmarried sisters, always available to comment on the misfortunes of others. And there’s the impassive butler Buttermere, before whom all censor their discussions, though he clearly couldn’t care less about any of them.

It will all sound familiar to anyone who has read one or more of Dame Ivy’s books. They’re all very much the same, though some are livelier than others, some more outright funny in their pitch black sort of way. To a large extent, they’re interchangeable (even to their titles, which are always conjunctive—Daughters and Sons, Parents and Children, The Mighty and Their Fall, The Present and the Past, etc.). And yet, there truly is something about them. I found myself thinking of Greek tragedy while reading Men and Wives—Aeschylus domesticated for the nuclear family but retaining many of the rudiments—passions, malice, vengeance, hubris, domination, jealousy—similarly stylized and formal, and always featuring a chorus of subsidiary characters to comment on the mayhem.

These novels are hard not to put down (at about the halfway point of Men and Wives, I found myself considering starting a different book, for a break if nothing else—the intensity, even leavened by dark humor, does take it out of one), but I resisted the urge, and ultimately, at the end of it all, I did—as I have eight times before—feel I’d experienced something rather awesome.

And now, there’s four more of Dame Ivy’s books on my shelves. Do I feel like another awesome experience right away?

Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Book report: ELIZABETH ELIOT (2 of 2)


Eliot's third novel, Mrs. Martell (1953), follows an utterly self-absorbed, superficial woman from her teens to her second marriage. But if that sounds unpleasant, in Eliot's hands it's not at all. Obsessed with money and class and all the appearances of a sophisticated life, but coming herself from genteel poverty, Cathie Martell rarely loses her focus on getting what she wants out of life, regardless of the feelings or happiness of those (her Aunt Violet, for example, who finances her education, or her first husband, or the man she's set her sights on to be her second—not to mention that man's current wife) who get in her way.

A critic's blurb about Mrs. Martell, from the back cover of Eliot's subsequent novel Starter's Orders (1955), says, "Only an artist in character study could make Cathie Martell tolerable; Miss Eliot goes further and makes her real." And it is indeed remarkable that the novel is so completely enjoyable despite having such an unlikeable main character. But I think it's Eliot's sharp eye for detail and her sense of humor that allow her to pull it off.

Another terrible photo, but the best I could
find for this book

The humor is a bit more muted here than in her first two novels (another critic notes that this is so "because wickedness is a sad business"), but it's still very much present. Sometimes it's that wonderful surprise ending to an otherwise innocuous observation, as here when Cathie is bored on a train and wishes for a handsome man to help her pass the time:

Even so, an encounter with a tall and handsome stranger would have been a pleasant interlude, but alas, he did not appear. Once, in the corridor, and right at the beginning of the journey, she thought she had found him; but later when he came into the dining-car he was surrounded by a gaggle of five or six bright adolescents all of whom addressed him as 'Daddy'; and they were accompanied by a depressed middle-aged woman who inevitably was Mother; impossible to imagine her as having ever been anything else.

One imagines the poor Mother must have sometimes had trouble imagining herself as anything else too! And here, in a dispute with Aunt Violet, a younger Cathie lets her propensity for drama get the best of her:

'As far as I am concerned, Aunt Violet, I don't want another penny of your money. I can go out and earn my bread,' and she saw a distinct picture of herself working her fingers to the bone and being seduced by goodness knows whom.

Blurbs from the back cover of Starter's Orders

And once or twice, even in this more serious novel, Eliot drops in an instance of pure silliness, as in this discussion at a ski lodge after one of Cathie's companions breaks a collar bone:

'Such a shame to break something at the beginning of the fortnight.' The elderly lady who had waylaid Laura in the hall of the hotel clicked anxiously over her knitting-needles.

'Yes,' Laura agreed, 'oh, yes.'

'When I was out here with my boys last year, we had two broken legs; but only on the very last day.'

'Even so, it must have been dreadful.'

'Of course they didn't both belong to us.'

Like most of Eliot's other novels, I think Mrs. Martell is a novel that will only improve on re-reading.

I did say "most," because, although it saddens me to admit that a new favorite author has her flaws, I'm not quite so sure that the same is true of Eliot's fourth novel, Starter's Orders (1955).

Front flap from
Starter's Orders

Now, if you're a big fan of horseracing, and are looking to read about it in fairly intimate detail—exploring the thoughts and feelings not only of the principle characters (a stable owner and the woman who may become his wife), but also of grooms and trainers and owners and bookies and gamblers, as well as several relatives and servants of the main characters—then you'll be happily in your element here. But those—like me—who can hardly tell the difference between a horserace and a game of croquet are likely to find less excitement here.

Starter's Orders seems to be in the nature of an experiment for Eliot—an attempt at a Dickensian variety of character with the budget-busting cast of thousands that a Hollywood extravaganza has on offer. And since Eliot is a polished and very talented author, I admit that even some of the scenes showing the care and handling of horses, or detailing the anxious preparations for a race, did pull me in and hold my interest, added to the fact that, when the focus is on the main characters and their slowly progressing relationship, Eliot produces more or less her usual sparkling, entertaining prose. Plus, even a not-entirely-successful novel can be interesting when examining a very good author's body of work, so perhaps I will revisit the novel someday and see what I come up with.

By contrast, however, Eliot's fifth and final novel, Cecil (1962), which appeared after an uncharacteristic seven year gap in publication, tops off her too-short literary career in style. Here, Eliot tries to get at something very subtle and elusive—portraying a dysfunctional (to say the least) mother/son relationship from the perspective of an in-law who only sees them now and again over the course of several years. Anne, the narrator, is the sister-in-law of the title character, and although she develops strong feelings about Henry and his mother, Lady Guthrie, one is also aware that her knowledge and perception is limited.

In lieu of a cover image of
Cecil, the back flap of Starter's
Orders
, with enthusiastic praise
for Alice

Eliot's intent is clearly not to make the relationship obvious, but to show it only as it can be wrestled with and perceived in glimmers and fragments and suspicions. It's an ambitious project, and one that fans of Henry James, for example, may happily sink their teeth into, but it's also always a fascinating and entertaining project. Just as I recently wrote about Rachel Ferguson's Evenfield, Eliot too manages to create genuinely serious literature without making the reader's experience feel like serious work. The shades of meaning and possible interpretations are there if you want to sample them, but you'll have fun even if you don't.

What's more, Cecil is an excellent portrayal of a theme I haven't commented on here for a while—that of the maleficent malingerer, here encapsulated in Lady Guthrie, who (if Anne's observations are to be believed) ruins the life of her son as thoroughly as if she set out to do so meticulously and calculatedly (but wait, perhaps she did?). Yet even as loathsome as she seems, I found Lady Guthrie completely believable, not just a comic book villain, and there are no easy answers for her or any of Eliot's other characters. And perhaps even Lady Guthrie's loathsomeness, as observed by Anne, is placed in some doubt, for one may wonder how much of it is real and how much is built up in Anne's own mind:

Lady Guthrie and Cecil arrived, as threatened, on the sixth of August. I had not, as I have said, seen Cecil for nearly three years or Lady Guthrie for seven. In the interval my feelings towards her, mainly, naturally, owing to the circumstances which had surrounded the breaking off of the engagement, had undergone a considerable change. As I waited for the carriage I realized that whereas before I had been accustomed to think of her as a selfish and often foolish woman I now regarded her as a veritable ogress. In my imagination, untouched by any sight of the reality, the soft features had become witchlike; the embonpoint had turned to layers of repulsive flesh. My first sight of Lady Guthrie, not very surprisingly, proved me to have been completely wrong. The appearance of the woman who was ushered into the drawing-room differed very little from that of the one who had last left it in 1887.

I have to admit that I'm not entirely sure, even now, what to think of Cecil's relationship with his mother, and I can't decide if this is because Eliot handled her ending with just a bit too much subtlety, or if this impression—that one almost perceives the truth, that if one just strains a bit more, re-reads earlier passages, seeks the clues a bit more aggressively, then one will see it all—is precisely the point Eliot wanted to make—that we can never see all of the clues, never perceive all the truth about other people and their motivations. And this is not to mention the ways in which the narrator's speculations sometimes reflect upon her own relationships with her husband and children—and perhaps the ways in which her ability to understand Cecil and his mother are limited by her own experiences as a mother.

Certainly, some dark secret about Cecil is implied here and there, but it is kept as vague as the misbehavior of schoolboy Miles in James's The Turn of the Screw, of which Cecil's implied but vague crimes reminded me.

But even feeling not completely sure about the ending, this is one of my favorite Eliot novels (though it's true I've felt that about all of her novels as I've finished them, except for the aforementioned Starter's Orders). More serious than the others, and somewhat inexplicably set in the late Victorian period—though its tone feels just the same as the others which are set in the 1950s—it nevertheless sparkles with Eliot's sharp observations and charming prose. It's less laugh-out-loud funny than her earliest works, though it does still have its moments, and I can't resist sharing one longish dialogue between Anne and Lady Guthrie, from very early on, as they discuss Lady Guthrie's current interest in spiritualism:

'If it hadn't been for the poltergeists,' idly Lady Guthrie picked up the silver trumpet used for blowing out the little spirit lamp under the kettle, 'I am convinced that my private hour with him would not have ended as it did.'

Exactly how the hour had ended she had not told us but apparently she and Mr Jackson had failed to communicate with the spirit of her sister Marion.'

I nodded sympathetically, thinking what a pity it was that of all Lady Guthrie's sisters, Marion, the only one who had died, should also be the only one in whose advice, if only it could be obtained, she seemed to place any confidence.

'Perhaps,' I said, 'if you were to try again on your way back through London?'

'I shall certainly attempt it but sometimes with so many wishing to speak to us it can be very difficult. On Sunday at the public meeting there were a great many messages; most of them I'm bound to say rather silly.'

Abruptly Lady Guthrie, without attempting to do anything supernatural with it, which is what I'd been vaguely afraid of, replaced the trumpet on the tea-table. 'Half of them might just as well have been written on the back of picture postcards of Brighton, "All well here, everything very beautiful, don't worry."'

What a shame that Eliot didn't continue to write fiction after 1962. As wonderful as Alice and Henry are, she evolved tremendously as an author by 1962, and I would have loved to see where she might have got to if she had gone on. From the beginning, she was a very smart, sophisticated, and clever author, and by 1962 she had become a very subtle one as well. She certainly deserves to be more widely read…

Tuesday, January 14, 2014

F[LORA]. M[ACDONALD]. MAYOR – The Squire's Daughter (1929)


In my younger, more cynical days, I went through a long phase of being obsessed with the wild, liberated days of the 1920s.  At the time I started reading Hemingway and Fitzgerald and their ilk, I was just making my escape from a rather dysfunctional upbringing in rural Missouri, and the culture of the Roaring Twenties, with its portrayals of carefree, sophisticated, unentangled lives in places like Paris and New York, somehow helped to break me free of the past and imagine possibilities for my life quite different from those I had ever encountered in reality.

That I often missed the larger meanings of these novels in the midst of my romanticizing is understandable enough, considering I was still a teenager, though the fact that I recall actually admiring cold, jaded characters like Hemingway’s Lady Brett Ashley is rather more embarrassing to admit.  But I also came across Carl van Vechten’s Parties (1930), a much gayer (in all senses of the word) take on the period, which I do still love for its rather daft, zany spin on the morbid self-absorption of the Lost Generation, and which may also have served a liberatory purpose for me. 

At the time, these male writers’ portrayals of glamorous, stoical, tormented, but always witty objects of desire apparently seemed perfectly believable to me.  But in more recent years, and under the influence of the many women writers I neglected in younger days, I’ve wished that I could know a bit more about them—what kinds of families do Lady Brett and Daisy Buchanan come from?  What are they like when there are no men around to be seductive for?  Do they read?  Deal with servant problems?  Torture shopgirls with their imperious demands?  And what might they find to say to one another if they could be friends and really talk, rather than just dishing out cutting one-liners or casual dismissals of tradition?

What got me thinking about all of this again (for better or worse) was my recent reading of Flora MacDonald Mayor’s The Squire’s Daughter.  This novel seems to be generally considered the ugly stepsister of Mayor’s other two novels, The Third Miss Symons (1913) and The Rector’s Daughter (1924).  Three years ago or so, I read both of those (and the latter became one of my all-time favorites), but somehow I got distracted before proceeding to Mayor’s final novel, in part, I think, because what I'd read about it made it seem an unenticing read.  That’s a shame, really, because in the end it proved to be a fascinating and thought-provoking novel, and in some ways it convincingly portrays the kinds of conflicts that real flappers might have experienced when they weren’t being idealized and objectified by male writers.

Ron de Lacey (short for Veronica) is the flapper in question here—deeply conflicted and living a life that alternates between wild jags in London and quiet, bored times with her family on the country estate in Carne.  Janet Morgan, in her introduction to the Virago edition, notes that Mayor was unfamiliar with the wild lives of 1920s youth and that therefore the London scenes are not totally convincing.  For example, this early description reads perhaps a bit too much like a bad Hollywood portrayal of the period:

She liked to be thought hot stuff, and Nadine, who wanted to keep on her good side, flattered her and incited her to escapades.  She went about street singing, and took in Myra and Uncle Merrick.  She dressed in men's clothes, and accompanied Nadine as her partner to a thé dansant.  She flirted attractively with the girls, and they did not find her out.  Sometimes her adventures were less amusing and more disreputable.

But Ron’s central conflict, between tradition and liberation, and her resistance to playing the title role as daughter of the squire, is convincing enough, and is effectively summed up just a couple of paragraphs later:

Ron had many memories to foster them.  Her childhood with dear, strict Nana; her companionship at Carne with tile village children, the old people, the animals, the affectionate village mothers; the park and gardens where she often rambled in secret childish meditation; her boarding-schooI, and jolly, spoiling friendships with girls and mistresses, above all her father; their play and jokes, and rides on his shoulders; when she was older their long interminable walks round and round the rose-garden after dinner arm-in-arm, with Stephanie calling that she must come in and go to bed, or sitting together in the big study chair when she talked to him about everything. After she came to London she often derided his opinions; much went on there she would not have them know at Carne, but underneath its influence continued, stronger than the louder, more insistent present.

Ron is under pressure to function as the squire’s daughter because her brother Oswald has earned their father’s lasting contempt due to his unwillingness to enlist during WWI, and her sister Colette is too empty-headed to be of use.  Meanwhile, her aunt Laura is something of an alter-ego—representing the previous generation’s “squire’s daughter” who gleefully leapt into her conservative role and continues in it to this day:

Laura treated her corner of Kensington as if it were her own village; she created a county atmosphere in the shops she visited, even the tax and water-rate men became part of the retinue.  She had a like-minded circle of friends, busy widows, and spinsters, vicars, retired soldiers and Indian civilians.  They all stood for Church, King, the Services, Public Schools, and Primrose League.  One can guess their many, many aversions.

Ron’s evolving attitude toward Laura, from mockery of her traditional values to a sort of ambivalent admiration for her self-assurance and ability to cope with difficult situations, epitomizes the conflicts of the novel.  That Ron is not always totally likeable in this process, and veers so wildly between her two contrasting lives, may be part of the reason that critics have tended to see this as Mayor’s weakest work.  But as Morgan goes on to say in her introduction, Ron “is confusing because she is confused, unaware of her own nature, torn between bravely trying to grow from a spirited girl into a serene and confident woman and, resisting what may be no more than the temptation to play an accepted role, determinedly staying as she is.”

And similar conflicts are visible in the culture at large:

"Carne is one of our beauty spots," said the local guide-book, and it was to have its beauty improved. The County and District Councils and business enterprise had their eye on it. Hedges were to be cut down, tall elms felled, thatched cottages destroyed, pavement laid beside the grassy roads, old, bowery, odd, twisting, pleasant, sudden corners standardized to insignificance. There was to be concrete, corrugated iron, pink asbestos roofs and yellow boards proclaiming petrol everywhere.

…

But the modern spirit, the spirit of grumbling, was rife here as elsewhere: the road was difficult for charabancs, and why was there no linoleum factory as at Searle? Sharp village children attending Bainbridge High School came back dissatisfied with thatched cottages up little winding lanes.

In regard to some of my favorite themes, Laura is, of course, a prime example of spinsterhood at its most useful and conservative, and Ron’s mother, Stephanie, is a rather sad example of a maleficent malingerer—a delicate little hothouse flower who doesn’t get jokes, frets and whimpers to control her family with faux concern, but is ultimately shown rather compassionately as a lonely, confused, even tragic figure.

Ultimately, The Squire’s Daughter is a bit less bleak than The Rector’s Daughter, if also less polished and sustained in its brilliance.  I found it completely compelling and entertaining, even if it is unlikely to haunt me in the way that Rector’s Daughter continues to do.  As a much more complex and thoughtful portrait of the Roaring Twenties than male writers of the time gave us, though, The Squire’s Daughter should certainly be more widely read than it is.

And Mayor seems to have felt a bit freer about being funny here, as when Colette marries a wealthy American businessman and the family experiences culture shock in arranging the wedding at their local church.  Ron’s father tells Laura:

"Warriker isn't such a bad little fellow, but the mother sticks at nothing.  She wanted to move the tombs from the church. 'We could put them back where they were!' as she remarked."

But there is one particular outburst of comedy in the novel—at the expense, predictably enough, of a pretentious neighbor:

Lady Merstham sometimes worked in the garden, weeding a little, cutting off dead flowers a little, watering the unimportant things, and forgetting the important. The gardener combined contempt for her with a fond respect for gentry. "I just have to set one of the lads to tidy up where her ladyship's been, but it's a change for her after so much company."

Edith’s sewing matched her gardening. Mrs. Fuller wrote artfully, when the Sale of Work drew near. “I wonder if it would be convenient to send the things on the 5th. I know that’s early, but it’s nice to get everything in good time to see how much one has.” Then she undid all Edith’s brush and comb bags, and sewed them up again.

"Numbers of people's fingers are all thumbs," said Violet, "but Edith might just as well have no fingers at all."

(I’ve made a note of this line so I can steal it the next time someone asks me to do something requiring manual dexterity.  Sadly, it is true that when it comes to using my hands, at least for anything much beyond typing, I indeed might just as well have no fingers at all.)

Just one final point: Although the two novels have absolutely nothing to do with one another, I couldn't help thinking, while reading The Squire's Daughter, about the Winifred Duke novel I reviewed a week or two ago. There, the four daughters suffer under the domination of a patriarchal Victorian father who, effectively, ruins their chances at happiness. In the end, one of the sisters (briefly) muses about the cultural changes that resulted from World War I, and how the war put all of the petty dramas of their lives into perspective. 

I found myself thinking how much different those sisters' lives might have been had they been born just a bit later, and I also couldn't help thinking, despite Ron's occasionally grating self-absorption, how really deadly serious was the struggle many women were engaged in to break free of a tradition which kept them stifled.  If Ron hasn't quite figured out how to achieve a balance between a respectful appreciation of the past and the pursuit of her own fulfillment, a comparison with the sisters in Duke's novel nevertheless shows rather dramatically the astonishing progress she has already made and perhaps makes it a bit easier to forgive her shortcomings.

*     *     *

Janet Morgan’s introduction to the Virago edition also provides interesting background about Mayor’s life and other writings.  I've never had much information about her first published work—Mrs. Hammond’s Children—which Mayor published in 1901 under the pseudonym Mary Strafford.  Morgan describes it as a collection of stories “based on the relations among children and the kindnesses and cruelties they practise on one another.” 

She also mentions a work I had not previously heard of: “the slight but intriguing Miss Browne's Friend-A Story of Two Women, an exploration of a friendship between a suburban lady and a prostitute, published serially in the Free Church Suffrage Times.”  Sadly, neither of these works appear to be available anywhere, though both sound intriguing.  More for the Hopeless Wish List?

The blurb on the back cover of the Virago edition also notes that Mayor was a significant influence on Barbara Pym.  When I first read that, I thought it was daft, as Mayor (the passage quoted above notwithstanding) rarely even attempts the kind of hilarity or brilliant sarcasm we associate with Pym.  But now I'm not so sure.  It’s true that Mayor is less concerned with being funny, but there are nevertheless turns of phrase, or sharp, precise characterizations, on which one might indeed imagine a young Barbara Pym making notes…

Saturday, January 4, 2014

WINIFRED DUKE, The Dancing of the Fox (1956)


A few days ago, I wrote about finding this book at Russell Books in Victoria during our post-Christmas excursion. I'm always a little torn when I come across a book like this by an author I don't know, which looks interesting but really could go either way. But I was intrigued by the jacket description of this one, and when I read the opening paragraph, my seduction was complete:

The four sisters sat at breakfast on this October morning of the year 1930. They were all elderly, and as was frequently the case with women of their era and environment, looked as though they had never been young. The house they occupied was a quiet, old-fashioned residence, set in a London suburb originally regarded as fashionable, but now decaying and obsolete. All of them had been born in the same house, lived their whole lives in it, and alike seemed destined to die there when the time came. Papa had brought Mamma to it after they married. The family had never known any other home. Everybody called them the Ross girls, later the Ross sisters, and now, Louise, the second one, wryly supposed, they were known as the Ross old ladies, or even as the Ross old maids.

I'm so pleased that I did find this book irresistible, because I read it obsessively in our hotel room and on our flight home (to Andy's slight annoyance), and while it's not necessarily one of my all-time favorites, it proved to be very compelling, rather unusual, and quite striking in its exploration of some of the themes I'm most interested in.

It turns out that Duke was a crime writer of sorts, but not a traditional mystery writer.  Rather, she seems to have been more focused on the effects of crime, and on characters' varying perceptions and feelings about guilt and punishment.  Judging from a few reviews I found of earlier novels, she seems to have been particularly concerned with the Scottish legal system's possible verdict of "Not Proven."  This verdict was apparently similar, originally, to the U.S. and England's "Not Guilty" verdict, but gradually evolved into something like a middle ground, in which a jury has the option of acquitting the accused for lack of proof but nevertheless asserting that it remains unconvinced of his or her innocence.  I found this fascinating, and if you do too you can read the Wikipedia entry about it here.

Duke hasn't been added to my Overwhelming List yet, though she will be in a future update.  And I have to thank a relatively new friend of this blog for the information that she was born in Liverpool but spent most of her life in Edinburgh, which explains the vivid portrayal of Scotland and Scottish characters in many of her novels, including this one.  She was the daughter of a clergyman and apparently also wrote historical works and biographical fiction.  Thank you, John, for providing this information.  

(By the way, John has also provided me with a wonderful revelation about a certain mysterious author discussed here previously, which I'll be posting about soon…)

The Dancing of the Fox is admittedly a bit on the bleak side, but I found it fascinating.  As is apparently true of some of Duke's other novels, it's not so much a who-done-it as a what-happened-after.  Although Duke was apparently praised for the surprise endings in some of her works, there is no surprise here, plot-wise. We learn early on of the murder, the perpetrator and his victim, and even—because the novel begins in 1930 and flashes back to 1889—the fates of many of the other principal characters. This might make the novel a bit less satisfying for some readers, but also perhaps more interesting for those interested in character studies. Here, the study concerns the lingering effects on the Reeds, a conservative Victorian family (one very much after Ivy Compton-Burnett's heart, actually—dictatorial patriarch and all) of the murder of its youngest son, Edward, while on vacation in Scotland.


The structure of the novel is somewhat unusual, I think.  It begins, as quoted above, in 1930 with the four surviving Reed sisters, before flashing back to Edward's departure for and failure to return from his holiday on an unnamed Scottish island and eldest brother James's departure to search for him.  The news of Edward's death reaches to the family, and then we flash back to James's actual trip and the search for and discovery of Edward's body at the base of a cliff. Then we flash back yet again to witness Edward's trip and to enter the perspective of his killer—though, interestingly, the murder itself is never presented, so we are intriguingly left uncertain of some of the details.  Several family members, including two of the sisters, are required to travel to Scotland for the trial, after which the reader is presented with the effects of the entire experience on various family members.

It's a somewhat peculiar way of telling the story, but I found it surprisingly effective.  It even seemed to me to build up a kind of suspense, in spite of the fact that I already knew most of the salient details of the plot. Perhaps Duke used this unusual structure to highlight some of the other themes that are important in the novel.

I've written several times before of what I call "maleficent malingerers"—those figures which seem to have become a sort of stock character in middlebrow women's novels and which most often seem to be mothers who manipulate their children using their poor emotional or physical health as a weapon.  Here, however, the malingerer is the Compton-Burnett-esque Victorian father, a widower who is so selfish, whiny, snide, manipulative, and gleefully martyred at every turn that in the end many readers may feel as I did—that the real tragedy of the novel is that the wrong member of the family was murdered.

Unlike in a Compton-Burnett novel, however, wherein other characters (most entertainingly even the younger offspring of her domineering patriarchs) are often armed with intellect and subversive wit with which to defend themselves, Duke portrays Mr. Reed's offspring as intelligent and thoughtful, but also as fully cowed and beaten-down.  She seems particularly interested in the four spinster daughters whose lives are blighted by either (depending on your perspective) Edward's murder or their father's domination.  The novel both begins and ends with them in later years—alone together, eccentric, isolated, left behind by the world and culture around them.

I have an ongoing fascination—for whatever peculiar, deep-seated reason—with literary portrayals of spinsters (I doubt if that comes as a shock to any regular readers of this blog). So I was particularly intrigued by Duke's characterization of the sisters and their tragic limitations.  For example, when Mary, the oldest daughter—calmly efficient and capable in managing her father's household—is forced to travel to Scotland to attend the trial, her utter lack of any real world experience is made poignantly explicit:

The hotel, situated in a quiet street, was not large, but the rooms were lofty as compared with London standards, and the entrance-hall sufficiently opulent to awe the strangers. How could Edward have gone so gaily and confidently to that dreadful hydropathic, actually enjoying, as evidenced by his letters home, the crowds, the new faces, the unfamiliar routine? Mary fought back a sob. James was coming towards them after a parley with the manager, asking whether they would like a meal, or prefer to go straight upstairs.

Similarly, left at home with their father, we see how helpless Mary's sisters Lilian and Alice are as they anxiously await word of the verdict but are unable to even obtain a newspaper:

"Can't we get a paper?"

Lilian offered the suggestion in a dubious tone. At Wisteria Lodge evening papers were considered to be slightly ungenteel, an unnecessary pandering to an unsuitable craving for news, and wholly unfitted for their sex.

…

"I wish James or Frederick were here. They'd know, or one of them would get a paper himself and say nothing about it to Papa."

There are even indications of hysteria in the two sisters who are fully developed as characters, Mary and Alice (the others are barely seen or heard, apart from Louise's musing in the opening paragraph). This is appropriate for a tale set in 1889, when Freud was just beginning his studies of neurotic symptoms and, rather radically, concluding that the root cause was his upper class female patients' stultifying lives as overprotected hothouse flowers. Undoubtedly the sisters would have made fascinating case studies. Later, too, when Mary becomes engaged to a friend of Edward's, whom she meets during the trial, and is trying to convince herself that her father can be made to approve, the reader can imagine her blushing to herself at the merest approach to a thought of the acts required to produce offspring:

It ought to mean a fresh interest for him, the wedding, Mary's new prospects, and perhaps in time the desired grand-children. This last thought hardly formed itself in Mary's mind. It savoured of immodesty to imagine such a possibility.

We know from the beginning that her attempt to find happiness is doomed to fail, but Duke handles the tragedy elegantly, and Mary's position is summed up succinctly:

What was she to do? The prospect of defying Papa was unthinkable. Even with Mr. Goodwin's support she knew that she would never have the courage. Her whole life had ill prepared her for this crisis.

Although Duke seems to have a particular interest in the sisters, however, I should note that they are not always the central focus. Edward and his brothers are also well-developed characters, and there are some particularly strong passages set in Scotland—before Edward's murder and during James's search for him, as well as during the trial. Mrs. Wallace, James's landlady during the search, is a lively and entertaining character, as is her "strong silent type" of a husband, "Wullie."

Duke does make liberal use of Scottish dialect throughout these scenes, something which normally irritates me no end, but which didn't trouble me here and was even somewhat entertaining. This is obviously highly subjective though, so fair warning. And she offers rather vivid descriptions of Edinburgh, including this one from just after the murderer's trial has ended on a Saturday night and the siblings are unable to head home until Monday because their father has forbidden travel on the Sabbath:

In the cold November morning the city, sunk in haar, resembled the drawings illustrating that region in an old book which had enlivened her childhood. There was the same grey atmosphere, the same smoke, the same ugliness. The Scottish capital in 1889 was indeed a dour, joyless place. Bells rang out, jangling, discordant, contradicting one another, and crowds hurried to the various churches with a flat purpose which seemed to denote that they went from duty, and no other motive. The four Rosses went too, it never occurring to them to do anything else. Frederick sat rigid during the sermon in case some reference might be made to the trial, in which event James was thoroughly capable of rising and stalking out of the building. Mercifully there was none, and the murderer's victim's family emerged at the conclusion uncomforted and at a loose end for the rest of the day.

Among a fair number of new vocabulary terms I got from this novel was "haar," meaning fog I believe, and the Scots' apparent tendency to refer to hot water bottles as "pigs"?  You see, it's an educational reading experience as well as an entertaining one!

I never did quite determine the meaning of the novel's title in relation to its plot.  The full quote from Yeats, used as the epigraph, is: "When men are very bitter, death and ruin draw them on as a rabbit is / Supposed to be drawn on by the dancing of the fox." A lovely quote, and I assume it's meant to refer to the murder victim, but it could conceivably refer to the ways in which Duke's characters allow their lives to ruined—by the murder, by the domineering father, or by their own weaknesses.  You know how I love a double meaning!

I know I have a frightful tendency to write about books that are practically unobtainable. (Oddly, this one isn't even listed on Amazon US, as far as I can see, but Bookfinder does bring up some fairly reasonably priced results.) But I will make amends in the next week or two—next up are a Persephone title, readily available in a beautiful little grey edition, and an old Virago title still readily available (though unforgivably out of print).  Stay tuned!

Sunday, November 10, 2013

DODIE SMITH, A Tale of Two Families (1970)


This is another quite odd but very enjoyable novel (my favorite kind), but it's also true that perhaps it only peripherally fits this blog.  It was published a full ten years after the period I’m focused on here, and Dodie Smith, who wrote both the perennially popular I Capture the Castle (1948) and the classic children’s book The Hundred and One Dalmations (1956), both still widely read today, might not even fit the criteria of being "lesser-known."

But although I Capture the Castle has remained in print, Smith’s other five adult novels, which the ODNB refers to as “increasingly fanciful,” have mostly remained out-of-print—though judging from their price tags on Amazon they remain coveted by Smith fans.  The first three of those—The New Moon with the Old (1963), The Town in Bloom (1965), and It Ends with Revelations (1967), were finally reprinted in the U.K. by Corsair in 2012, but A Tale of Two Families and Smith’s final novel, The Girl in the Candle-Lit Bath (1978), remain out-of-print.  (And the fact that the Corsair editions are currently remaindered in the U.S. may not bode well for those titles staying in print for long either.)  So that portion of Smith’s oeuvre, at least, certainly seems to qualify as "lesser-known."

A quick Google search reveals that several other readers of the book had experiences similar to mine.  The beginning of the novel does read rather like a play (not too surprising, since Smith was also a successful playwright), and it takes a bit of getting into as the numerous characters and the novel’s "fanciful" premise are introduced.  However, once it does get moving, I found it hard to put down.

The basic plot revolves around two sisters—quirkily named May and June—who happen to be married to two brothers, George and Robert.  George is a successful businessman, charismatic and philandering; Robert is an acclaimed but commercially unsuccessful novelist; May channels her frustrations about George’s occasional flings into a sophisticated façade and careful attention to decorating and homemaking; while June is ineffectual but loving—perhaps too much so, as she seems to be in love with George as well as Robert. 

George and May lease the Dower House of a rather run-down country manor, and invite Robert and June to live in the staff cottage nearby.  Meanwhile, two of the couples' children, Corinna and Hugh, double cousins who are having a luke-warm, semi-incestuous, celibate-unto-marriage relationship (with the marriage placed some time vaguely in the future), remain in the family's London flat but put in occasional weekend appearances.  The brothers' father, Baggy, lives with George and May, and the sisters' glamorous septuagenarian mother, Fran, comes for a long visit.  Sarah, the friendly (and attractive, if it weren’t for her terrible voice) daughter of the manor also plays her part.  And I could hardly forget the curiously stunted, compulsively self-absorbed Aunt Mildred, who comes for a devastating visit.

Most of the key events of the novel take place in the gardens around the houses—including a lilac grove through which diverging and confusing paths pass and a wood where a nightingale sings.  The descriptions of the entire setup are calculated to make anyone with fantasies about English country life (such as those I just recently wrote about in relation to Ruth Adam's A House in the Country) drool with envy, but the garden and woods also seem intended to evoke Shakespeare’s Forest of Arden with its almost magical ability to create chaos and bring out hidden desires.  (The fact that Corinna is a budding actress who has recently stolen the show in As You Like It, outshining the lead actress with her Celia, is a clue—and the image of a second-fiddle stealing the show from a star seems like it ought to be symbolic of something, though I haven’t quite figured out what…)

All of which sounds like the perfect setup for a cozy comedy of love troubled, renegotiated, and rediscovered.  And it is.  Sort of.

In a couple of previous reviews, I’ve floated the concept of—for lack of a better term—the “uncozy,” a novel that has all the makings of a cozy little lark, and indeed can be read and enjoyed as nothing more, but which, if you're inclined to dig a little deeper, may actually subvert that coziness and be more disturbing and more profound than one might expect.  I think A Tale of Two Families has a claim to this designation as well, since—if I’m not reading too much into it, as I am admittedly prone to do—it seems to be surprisingly concerned with sex, and under the surface it may be a rather serious and sometimes dark exploration of female sexuality in particular.

The turning point of the novel, after all, hinges upon a fragile, undersized Dalmation puppy (of course—this is Dodie Smith, after all!), who is just, for the first time, "coming into season" as May calls it (Fran, characteristically, scoffs at this euphemism: "'Such a ridiculous expression,' said Fran. 'Sounds as if she's something to eat. My dogs, no doubt vulgarly, just came on heat.'")  Because of her delicate health, a pregnancy now would be potentially deadly, and there is much concern about keeping her under careful watch or carefully locked in a room.  Her escape from the house at the hands of rather disturbingly loony Aunt Mildred, who enjoys rape fantasies and feels that she simply must allow the dog to have her fling (and perhaps even vicariously enjoy it herself!), precipitates several major plot developments. 

Ahem.

In addition, the dog's instinctive urges seem to be paralleled or contrasted with several of the other characters: Corinna, growing restless in her pure, sexless romance with the saintly Hugh, half-heartedly attempts to seduce him and, when that fails, is driven into the arms of a famous middle-aged actor; June briefly gives in to her lust for George despite her very real love of Robert; Fran, it emerges, may have had a fling with Rudolph Valentino in her girlish days and certainly, like Corinna, had a fling with a famous theatre actor before settling down with May and June's father; and George tries halfheartedly to control his indiscriminate lust, musing at one point about how he relishes pinching young girls' butts.  All of them seem—at least in the somewhat magical setting of the lilac garden and woods—to be driven by, or resisting, or perhaps regretting the loss of, their sexual urges.


And then there's terrible Aunt Mildred, only three years younger than Fran, which puts her at around 69 years old, who is not only terminally (and hilariously) negative and condescending:

At the Dower House, Baggy and Robert came out to greet Mildred, Baggy having decided to please Fran by what he thought of as 'doing the civil' and Robert having been asked, by June, to be on hand. Mildred, her blue eyes at their widest, said to Baggy, 'Why, Mr. Clare!' (Baggy afterwards told Fran, 'She seemed amazed that I was still alive.') To Robert she said brightly, 'How's the writing?' somehow making it sound like a hobby, not a profession. Although she favoured the Dower House with a long look she made no comment on it, and that very fact was somehow an adverse comment.

but also seems stuck in a strange infantile obsession with sex—uninterested in actual intimacy, but perversely fascinated with the sex lives of others.  Her attire reflects her childish self-image:

Almost on Fran's heels came Mildred, in pink, frilled mousseline de soie, the waist up under her arms which dangled from little puffed sleeves. The dress reached to her calves and below it were frilled pantalettes and pink dancing sandals with crossed elastics. Ignoring the group now formed by Fran, Robert and June, she tripped over to the lilac grove, stood on tiptoe with her feet close together, and pulled down a spray to smell. The pose perfectly suggested an illustration to some long-ago child's picture book.

And when she mistakenly thinks that Hugh and Sarah have had a passionate interlude, she is thrilled to have a new fantasy:

He would have been surprised to know that what they'd been doing was of no great interest to Mildred. What mattered was what she intended to imagine them doing. At last she had a new toy. She could take it for walks, think about it before she fell asleep. And she felt sure it would be a lasting toy; she tired of some of them so quickly. But Hugh, this splendid new Hugh who had shouted at her, and that dark handsome girl...she would think about them all the coming week and then take them home with her.

One or two reviews of this novel online mentioned that its weak point was its rather Freudian (or, more accurately, pseudo-Freudian) perspective on sexuality.  As something of a Freudian myself, I don't necessarily agree that a Freudian perspective would be a weakness, though the popular version of Freud in play here—as in most popular culture—is patently absurd.  But regardless, it is certainly true that Mildred is presented as a kind of case study.  Various characters theorize about what caused her to become what she is—including George, who, from a typically offensive, seducer's point of view, suggests that "early and frequent rape might have made a different woman of her…"  [!!!]

But it is really Mildred's arrival that gets the novel rolling along entertainingly, and regardless of the causes of her disturbing behavior, her ultimate function here—apart from the fact that other characters' reactions to her are often quite funny—seems to be to act as the catalyst for the novel's crisis and as a sort of warning of one negative extreme of narcissistic sexuality.  Some of her behaviors are echoed, in milder form, in other women in the novel, so that the novel winds up forming almost a spectrum of various forms that women's sexual experience can take. 

And that seems somewhat remarkable to me, because even in 1970 when this novel was published, representations of actual female desire and sexuality (as opposed to idealized romances or tales of women as glamorous sexual objects) seem to have been fairly rare.  So I found myself impressed by Smith's daring and her ability to include an exploration of female desire in what is ultimately a light, highly-readable, very entertaining tale, without it seeming heavy-handed or lurid or in any way preachy.

One of the most likeable characters is Fran, an example of a sexually-liberated "free spirit" (so appropriate to the late 60s/early 70s period in which the novel is set) who has had a glamourous past and is now poignantly coming to terms with her increasing age, in part through her friendship (and maybe a wee bit of flirtation) with poor Baggy, who has a heart condition himself and has more or less resigned himself to doddering old age. 

We first see Fran with Baggy assuring him that she refuses to have rheumatism: "'I'm a bit stiff sometimes but I take no notice of it. Take notice of stiffness and it calls itself rheumatism. Get your mind off it and it goes away.'" But not long after, while returning from shopping to meet Baggy for tea, she has a fainting spell on the street, and when she arrives for tea and goes to the ladies' room, she sees an empty room on the landing and has a vivid flashback to her youthful Bloomsbury flat and an early, torrid romance:

And now she saw the lilac, masses of it in her two Devon pitchers, three jugs she had borrowed from the crone in the basement—and, of all things, a bucket! Masses and masses of long-stemmed white lilac. And now she could smell it and it didn't smell at all like the lilac at the Dower House now in full bloom. And in a flash, she knew why. What she was smelling in memory was the scent she had used in those old Bloomsbury days, a scent called Le Temps de Lilas. It was that scent which had caused him to inundate her with lilac she had been almost hysterical with pleasure when he arrived positively weighed down with it all. He had put it down on the floor and they had sat amongst it, laughing and kissing. And later… That had been the first time, so long remembered, so long forgotten—and now suddenly there.

But only for a moment, perhaps only for a split second. Then she was back in her seventies, a respectable elderly lady whose legs would no longer run. And she would be very, very glad of a cup of tea.

There is a sad and funny sequel to this later when, resisting the realization that her days of glamourous conquest are at an end, Fran sneaks into the garden after dark and repeatedly—but with limited success—attempts to run about.

The various resolutions in the novel are perhaps, like many of its events, a bit Shakespearean.  And like many of Shakespeare's endings, where the fantastic, passionate behavior of characters in the forest are so often reined in by death or marriage, the resolutions here are perhaps not all completely satisfying.  But the overall effect remains one of a highly entertaining farce, albeit with surprisingly profound and serious undertones.

However "fanciful" A Tale of Two Families might indeed be, though, I find it a bit shocking that it has never been reprinted.  Even if it can't stand up to a comparison with I Capture the Castle (and I don't think it can), it can certainly still be an intriguing companion-piece for it, and surely Castle's multitude of fans would find it interesting and entertaining.  Go figure!

Sunday, August 18, 2013

MARY BELL, Summer’s Day (1951)


There are few things so enjoyable to me as sitting down with a book of which I have fairly low expectations, only to find that it is fascinating in all sorts of ways I never would have expected.  That's something that doesn't happen often—call me cynical, but I find that my low expectations are quite often confirmed!—but it certainly happened with Mary Bell's Summer's Day, which has now been added to my top shelf of favorite novels—the ones with which I might well try to stagger out of a burning building, or for which I would scrabble in the rubble if the "big one" ever does hit San Francisco.

I was, in fact, all prepared to write only a rather condescending short post about how, really, I could hardly expect a novel about a girls' school to be exactly my cup of tea, but that it did have some mildly amusing high points.  (I would like to say that that I've learned my lesson about pre-judging books, but alas, I find that I learn slowly…)

The novel does take place in and around a girls' school before, during, and immediately after one summer term fairly soon after the end of World War II.  It features a large cast of entirely believable characters, including teachers, staff, students, and students' families, each with faults and charms, most of them likeable enough (though a few are perhaps likeable only with an effort).  The events are ordinary—the frustrations of youth, the disillusionments of maturity, the drudgery of students and teachers alike, unrequited love, infatuation, and even a seduction. 

But three main things make this, for me, much more than a run-of-the-mill read: the author's vivid attention to detail, which makes reading about a teacher preparing to leave her cottage for a new term as riveting as a major plot development; a brilliantly double-edged sense of humor, which can be riotously funny and darkly melancholy, sometimes at the very same time, and which almost always resonates with the realities and histories of the characters involved; and a depth and underlying seriousness that lends real meaning and significance to even trivial events.

Don't believe me?  Here's some of the aforementioned scene of Miss Meadows, a former classics mistress called out of retirement to fill a staffing need created by the war, preparing to leave her home for the term:

Her kitchen was a small, mouldy-smelling shrine dedicated to the evil spirit of a stove which smoked.  The sitting-room with its pseudo Adam fireplace, willow pattern china and Persian carpet was dustier than she would have liked to know, but at sixty-five she did not see dust very well.  The petals from the wild anemones on the piano made a little white drift on its rosewood surface.

I even found myself compulsively noting the very details I usually glide right over in other novels, not being a particularly visual kind of guy (to such an extent that once, attempting to pick out a throw rug at IKEA, I genuinely couldn't remember the color of the carpeting in an apartment I'd occupied for a year!).  And the reason is that, here, the detail is not just scene-setting or pretty background, but includes careful revelation of characters and their pasts.  Combine the above passage with this one, about Miss Meadows' return to her cottage during a holiday:

Letters, housework, mending, gardening, piled together, loomed like a trackless mountain at the back of her mind but she collected a deck-chair and the Iliad and sat down with her feet in the sun.

Taking just those two passages, you have a pretty clear idea of the life and priorities of one of the novel's most likeable characters—perhaps a stand-in for Bell herself, in the sense that Miss Meadows seems to represent balance and sanity and compassion in the midst of characters in greater turmoil.

As for humor, there are a few out-and-out hilarious scenes, such as this one demonstrating the lack of authority the art master, Mr. Walker, possesses over the girls:

After break the Upper Fifth trooped into the studio with much unnecessary noise.  Told to collect drawing-boards, somebody dropped one, and, as if this disaster were catching, twenty-five more clattered to the ground.  Informed that the grouping from the last class would not do for them, they expressed themselves eager to help and rearranged the room with such vigour that not a piece of furniture was still.  In vain Mr. Walker waved his arms and called upon them to desist while they interpreted his frantic mouthings as further exhortations to toil.  When some ten minutes of the period had been wasted they consented to sit down.

But in most cases, the humor has a deeper purpose.  Imagine the average writer managing to be so funny while packing so much detail and such a vivid sense of character into the following passage, in which Jasmine, a rebellious student yearning for life in the real world, waits outside the house mistress' office to be "corrected" for her latest infringement:

Three ill-mannered little girls went past and grinned at her; Jasmine looked coldly over their heads.  Matron, passing with a glance of quiet satisfaction, received a malevolent glare.  Miss Meadows went by with her lips moving, her eyes on the ground; as she put a pile of translations on her table she distinctly remembered seeing someone close at hand.  She looked into the corridor and asked kindly, “Can I do anything for you, dear?”  Jasmine thanked her and shook her head.  Miss Meadows realised she had been tactless and went away looking as if she thought Jasmine was paying a social call.

…

She was engaged in trying to stare the Giaconda out of countenance when Miss Cottingham, who had not, as Jasmine supposed, been keeping her waiting because she had taken a tip from a dictator but because she had been hastily putting three detective stories and nine undarned stockings behind the cushions, opened the door and beckoned her in.

I still laugh every time I see the "malevolent glare,"  and all of this would have been quite enough to make Summer's Day a highly enjoyable novel—perhaps even one of my favorites.  But in fact, Bell's purpose here is more profound than one would expect. 

When I wrote about Dorothy Evelyn Smith's Miss Plum and Miss Penny, I said one of the things I liked most was how Smith sort of subverted the whole concept of a "cozy" novel—injecting a fascinating depth and darkness into what at first appears to be a simple lark about life in an eccentric village.  Although Summer's Day is not as dark in its humor as Smith's book, it does perhaps belong in the same genre—the "uncozy," you might call it.

For ultimately, it seems to me that Bell's novel is a meditation on the largest themes of all: freedom and its limits, love and loss, ambition and frustration, hope vs. compromise—even mortality itself (for it is surely not coincidental that one of the only literary quotes in this highly literary work is of Shakespeare's "Fear no more the heat of the sun" passage).  Perhaps even the title, which seems quite innocuous, may be meant to suggest that a glorious summer day still must end in night.

Take a look at this passage from the opening of the novel, in which the elderly housemaid, Alice, recalls when the current Matron, Miss Bishop, arrived at the school as a student.  Right away, we know that this is more than a simple school comedy or romance:

The father was dead, the old headmistress in her dotage; Alice was quite certain that Miss Bishop herself did not remember it.  The child, in her opinion, had done well to cry, might reasonably have increased her vehemence had she foreseen herself growing into the detached, successful woman who considered it her duty to be calm and cheerful.  Alice wasted no pity on the past self who had witnessed those tears; she had changed from a young pretty parlour-maid to an old and stout one, with little difference in her state beyond an increase in her salary and her blood pressure.

Later on, we meet May Tern, Jasmine's aunt who adopted her when her parents were killed and who is stuck in a loveless marriage with a dull, demanding churchman:

When her doubts as to the wisdom of the union had become a certainty, and she could see the rest of her life stretching in front of her as a desert of dreary acquiescence, the two-year-old girl had been deposited upon her nearest relatives.  Unlike Mrs. Tern, Jasmine appeared to fear no one; from the first she had bawled with a sturdy indifference to her uncle’s comfort which had immediately endeared her to her aunt.  At sixteen she had formed a bond of mutual resistance with that lady, which, if it could not defeat the Reverend Arthur Tern, could usually circumvent him.  Together they preserved a façade of decorous obedience and enjoyed themselves immensely in his absence.

And later in the book, this brief thought from May on her surname (Tern) made me laugh out loud but is also undoubtedly a bit melancholy:

A ridiculous name, she thought, reaching for one of Arthur’s stamped envelopes.  As if I were a worm.  Only of course I never do.

Get it?

The larger themes of the novel are never heavy-handed.  Bell isn't trying to make any kind of big point or pontificate about anything.  Rather, practically every line just resonates naturally with undercurrents of meaning, and that, it seems to me, is what makes a novel great.

But in addition to the grand themes I already mentioned, there may be one more that's rather surprising.

Scholar Edward Said famously wrote a few years back about the colonial subtexts of Jane Austen's novels, pointing out how many of her characters are in some ways identified with or have made their money from imperialist pursuits.  A lot of Austen fans were annoyed by this or thought it was beside the point, but for me it made Austen's novels that much richer and more complex. 

Surprisingly, some of that same kind of content is present here.  Two of the novels' male characters are stationed or working in Africa, and the gardener, Albert, spent time in Algiers during the war and remembers it vividly.  Jasmine and her friend Sophie romanticize the men's work in naïve and idealized ways, as when Tom asks Jasmine to write to him:

“It’s a long way,” she said, imagining her letter embarking at—would it be Southampton?—and cruising off over the Atlantic, a touch of Mediterranean at Gibraltar, the Atlantic again…

“Will you?” asked Tom, hoping she saw him as a rather heroic figure in a topee, scanning the horizon for the mail.

“Oh, yes!” said Jasmine.  Her letter had arrived, it was being taken from the mail bag by—would it be black hands or white?—black, she was certain.  “I should love to,” she said.  Tom received the smile that was intended for the enormous negro who went bounding up the hill with her letter in his hand.

Rather interesting, too, that she winds up placing herself in Tom's position, receiving the very letter she has sent! 

Even Jasmine's mother gets in on the fantasizing in a humorous way, as when she interrupts Tom's talk about the wilds:

“No, dear, don’t,” May interrupted, for it worried her to think of poor Tom surrounded by cannibals and mosquitoes and striding—she was sure he strode—through endless tracts of heat and dust.

Ultimately, I wondered if the elegiac tone of the novel may perhaps apply to the decline of the British Empire as well, since by the time this novel was written most readers would probably have read Jasmine's fantasies of exotic locales with some irony.  They do seem to hark back to a time when the world really was Britain's oyster.

Before concluding this overlong (and gushing) post, I should point out one of the recurring themes of a lot of the books I've mentioned here: the "maleficent malingerer."  In this case, it's Mr. Walker's terrible mother, who pretends to be weak and helpless in order to control every part of her son's life—even stashing money away in an effort to keep him too poor to marry.  But as Mr. Walker begins to experience a romantic interest (no, don't worry, no spoilers here!), she has difficulty maintaining control, as in the following, hilarious passage that perfectly sums up the passive-aggressive's strategies.  Here, she awaits his return home, unaware that he has lost track of time in feminine company:

In the house his mother removed invisible specks of dust from the carpet and reminded herself to tell her son to wipe his feet.  Suddenly she decided to move the piano and having turned it half-round and rucked up the carpet she waited to be found, martyred and helpless, left to struggle with such odds alone.

…

In the house, Mrs. Walker, despairing of an audience, squeezed two tears on to an antimacassar and pushed the piano back against the wall.

Obviously, I could quote from this novel all day long, because there is hardly a line that isn't worth noting.  But this makes the mystery of Mary Bell's identity even more irritating. 

Original dust jacket (from the Greyladies edition)

When Greyladies reprinted Summer's Day a few years ago, they searched for traces of Bell and were unable to find her or her heirs.

It's unusual, if not unheard of, for a writer to appear out of nowhere, write a really accomplished and fascinating novel, and then vanish again.  It's reminds me of Virginia Woolf's famous speculations about Judith Shakespeare, the equally brilliant (fictional, at least as far as we know) sister of the Bard, who, because of the limitations of women's lives, lack of time and privacy, lack of education and opportunity and independence, never fulfilled her promise. 

The only other trace of Mary Bell in the British Library catalogue is a book called Broken Bonds (1946).  This appears to have been a romance (or at least marketed as such), since it appeared in the "New Moon Series" published by William Stevens, an imprint that appears to have been dedicated to very short romance stories (featuring advertisements geared toward women throughout).  It's not certain that this is the same Mary Bell, but it does seem plausible.

Could Bell have written other works as well?  Could she have published under a pseudonym (or could "Mary Bell" have been a pseudonym itself)?  Perhaps we even know of works written by her under a different name?  Or is it that she wrote other books that never found a publisher?  Could there be unpublished manuscripts somewhere, in the attic of a nephew who doesn't even know that Aunt Mary used to always be scribbling on a notepad?  Or did Mary Bell, like so many other women, devote herself to marriage and motherhood, or to a more stable and lucrative career than writing, and never give her creative urges another thought?

Moreover, I wonder, could Bell have had a husband or brother stationed in Africa or the Middle East, or could she herself have lived there?  Her descriptions of being on a ship in harbor in Africa, and of Albert’s forays into the seedier parts of Algiers, are strikingly vivid (and form a sharp and effective contrast with Jasmine's naïve fantasies of these locales).

Is there any chance that we'll ever find answers to such questions?  Alas, perhaps not.  It's rather maddening to the obsessive-compulsive data-gatherer in me, I can tell you!

But at any rate, I am thankful to Greyladies for retrieving this novel from total obscurity and putting some copies into circulation so that I was able to stumble across it recently. It is now out-of-print again, but it's definitely worthy of being retrieved permanently.  Perhaps Persephone or Capuchin or Bloomsbury or some other savvy publisher should jump on it.  It's certainly better than many of the novels that are reprinted time and again.

Can you tell I liked it?  :-)

[If you haven't already, be sure to check out my subsequent post on Mary Bell's identity. The mystery, or part of it at least, has been solved.]
NOTE: The comment function on Blogger is notoriously cranky. If you're having problems, try selecting "Name/URL" or "Anonymous" from the "Comment as" drop-down (be sure to "sign" your comment, though, so I know who dropped by). Some people also find it easier using a browser like Firefox or Chrome instead of Internet Explorer.

But it can still be a pain, and if you can't get any of that to work, please email me at furrowed.middlebrow@gmail.com. I do want to hear from you!